old abandoned car junkyard night with red light

What Are The Pros and Cons of Buying Used Cars from a Dealer?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Is the purchase of a used vehicle on your horizon? Do buy a used automobile from a dealer or a private person have any advantages or disadvantages? Buying a used car may be an intimidating and stressful affair.

    Consider each choice's benefits and drawbacks to determine which is best for you. This article details both options' benefits (and potential dangers), allowing you to choose between purchasing from a dealership versus purchasing from an individual.

    Advantages Of Purchasing From A Retailer

    Facilitating Action

    The purchase of a vehicle, even a used one, is a significant investment for most of us, second only to purchasing a home. For the unprepared or untrained, this can quickly become a stressful situation.

    Car dealers relieve some of this stress because selling vehicles is their profession. In addition, they have experience with the process and are familiar with the forms, declarations, and other documentation that must be filed.

    Guaranteed Service And Protective Laws

    The fact that dealers are required to adhere to Australian Consumer Rules and the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act's statutory warranty is one of the many benefits of purchasing from a dealer that needs to be more understood and appreciated.

    The minimum state warranty covers vehicles that cost more than $4000, are less than 12 years old, and have fewer than 180,000 kilometres on the odometer. The warranty will last for one or three months, depending on how old the car is and how many miles it has been driven.

    Dealers typically evaluate and fix any issues with used cars before selling them. Nonetheless, a second independent inspection is still worth considering if you want complete peace of mind.

    Facilitated Banking

    Dealers are in the best position to assist you with financing if you need help to make ends meet. However, securing financing on your own, particularly for a used vehicle, may take time and effort.

    Greater Density Of Vehicles

    Dealerships typically provide a wide variety of pre-owned vehicles, making them convenient for comparison shopping. Used vehicles from various automakers, not pre-owned Cars, are always for sale at Old Cars Removed. You may come across an option that works for you that you hadn't thought of before.

    Problems Inherent With Dealer Purchases


    When purchasing from a dealer, expect to pay a higher price because they are a business that must turn a profit to stay in business. There may be less room for discussion because of that, too. But it shouldn't put you off looking at dealers for your next used automobile; the price gap may not be as large as you believe.

    If you want to upgrade but your present car is in decent shape, you could trade it in at the dealership. While you might earn more money by selling it privately, trading it in through a dealership is much easier and less stressful to obtain a better bargain on the car you want.

    High-Pressure Marketing

    Some salesmen can be overeager due to their reliance on sales commissions. The most effective ones are those who pay attention to your needs and preferences and work with you to find solutions that work for you long-term. You can either complain to the sales manager or move your business elsewhere if you encounter someone too pushy.

    What Are The Benefits And Disadvantages Of New Vs Used Cars?

    It's time for a new pair of wheels, but with costs going up, wait times getting longer, and "semiconductor specials" that require you to "make do," should you look at pre-owned vehicles instead?

    It's hard to believe in fate when there are so many convenient methods to buy a brand-new automobile online or off, and you can pick out the precise model you want without having to deal with the boogers of the previous owner on the dashboard.

    The used-car industry isn't exempt from price gouging, especially in the collector's market, but you might find a lot better deal there than you would on a brand-new model. So if you're looking for advice on purchasing a car, here are the benefits and drawbacks of both new and pre-owned models.

    Advantages Of Purchasing Brand-New

    dump broken rusted cars their parts tires

    The Power To Decide

    Choosing your ideal trim, colour, options, and engine is much easier when you buy brand new. A new car from a dealership offers a wide variety of choices and a tailored purchasing experience for those who know what they want and are willing to pay (and wait) for it. As a result, the vehicle you select will be ideal for your needs.

    Modern Equipment

    Wireless smartphone mirroring and modern navigation systems are examples of cutting-edge technology that will save you money in the long run. It's only sensible to modernise as life becomes increasingly dependent on technology. You'll also save money at the gas station thanks to cutting-edge engine technology.

    Calm Confidence

    The manufacturer's guarantee is probably the biggest selling point. Today, you can buy a car with a warranty lasting five, seven, or even ten years from several manufacturers. In addition, the increasing availability of capped-price servicing contracts that provide a detailed breakdown of regular expenses makes it much simpler to plan.

    Negative Aspects Of A Brand-New Purchase

    It's Very Pricey

    The gap between the prices of new and secondhand automobiles is narrower than it has ever been. Nonetheless, it would be best if you still accounted for depreciation. Although if it isn't as awful as it was before the epidemic (and savvy investors who bought a Toyota GR Yaris are probably chuckling to themselves right about now), it's certainly something to think about if you're in the market for a family vehicle.

    There Is Likely To Be A Long Wait

    The specifications will have to be reduced. Subaru Forester 2.5X and Volkswagen Tiguan Allspace Adventure are two examples of brands that have released tech-light specials in Australia; for a brief period, BMW also sold vehicles without touchscreens. This is because it can take anything from three to eighteen months to get a full-fat automobile. An option that has been lightly used starts to look appealing at that time.

    Fewer Service Providers are Available

    If you wanna get the best out of your warranty, you may have to have all your maintenance done at the dealership where you bought the automobile. It's a plus for Toyota and Honda, but only a few manufacturers have reasonably priced service plans. When serviced at a dealership, Mitsubishi's guarantee is extended to ten years or 200,000 kilometres.

    What Else Should You Know About Pre-Owned Vehicles?

    There are many more considerations than the automobile's make and model when shopping for a secondhand car. Other considerations are as follows:

    History Of The Car

    An important consideration while shopping for a used automobile in Melbourne is the car's past. The reason is a vehicle's past can reveal a lot about its current state and any issues it may have. For instance, whether or not an automobile has been in an accident can hint at how well it has been maintained and whether or not there are any hidden problems.

    In a similar vein, understanding the service history of an automobile can give you an idea of its general condition and the likelihood of its long-term dependability. You may learn a lot about the worth of a car and whether or not it's a wise purchase by looking into its past.

    The Auto's State Of Repair

    Check for deterioration, damage, and corrosion. It may be required to hire a professional inspector to spot any issues.


    Whether you're in the market for a used automobile in Melbourne or elsewhere, knowing the vehicle's mileage will give you a good sense of the level of tear and wear you can expect. The mileage of a vehicle is the total distance driven by the vehicle since it was first driven off the lot.

    A vehicle with a higher mileage has likely been driven more frequently, increasing the likelihood that it will need additional maintenance or repairs due to the increased wear and tear. Nonetheless, a vehicle with low mileage may be preferable because it shows fewer signs of wear and may still have many years of useful life ahead of it.

    The number of miles an automobile has been driven might also reduce its worth. In the secondary market, a vehicle with fewer miles driven will sell for a greater price.

    Ownership History

    Many owners of a car may be an indication of mechanical issues that forced its prior owners to sell it.

    Financing Options

    Always shop around for the best interest rate and terms when financing a vehicle.


    Find out if the dealership provides extended warranty plans or if there is still time on the manufacturer's warranty.

    Test Drive

    Take the automobile out for a spin and see how it performs on the road.

    Car Insurance

    When looking for a used automobile in Melbourne, it's also necessary to consider auto insurance. Before buying a used car, it's important to verify whether or not the current owner has adequate insurance coverage. Reasons why are as follows:

    • Driving without auto insurance in Australia can result in heavy fines and perhaps the suspension of your driver's licence. As a result, check that the vehicle's insurance is current before making the purchase.
    • Damages and medical bills from car accidents can add up quickly, and if you were at fault, you could be held financially responsible for those expenses. Getting sufficient auto insurance helps safeguard your financial well-being and pay repair costs in the event of an accident.
    • Your auto insurance might impact the ownership experience, as some policies contain stipulations that limit the vehicles covered or how they can be used. Verifying the car's insurance status might save you time and money in the long run.


    The article compares and contrasts purchasing a pre-owned vehicle from a dealer to purchasing one from an individual. Buying from a dealer has its benefits, including familiarity with the process, service guarantees, and protections from the law.

    Vehicles that cost more than $4000, are less than 12 years old, and have fewer than 180,000 kilometres on the odometer are covered by the statutory warranty established by the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act, which dealers must uphold.

    While it is true that car dealerships will inspect and repair any problems with a used vehicle before selling it, a buyer may want to consider getting a second opinion. Used car dealerships typically stock a wide selection of vehicles, making it easy to do research.

    However, buying from a dealer comes with its own set of issues, such as higher prices and pushy sales tactics.

    With so many easy options for purchasing a new car, both offline and online, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of buying new versus used.

    Buying a new car gives you options, cutting-edge conveniences, unshakeable self-assurance, and reassurance from the manufacturer.

    Although the gap between brand-new and used car prices is narrower than ever before, it is still prudent to factor in depreciation. Depreciation should still be accounted for, even though the gap between new and used car prices is smaller than it has ever been.

    When looking for a used car in Melbourne, it is important to keep in mind the car's history, that there is likely to be a long wait for a full-fat automobile, and that there are few service providers available.

    That's because information about the car's history, like whether or not it has been in an accident, can shed light on its current condition and any problems it may be experiencing. A vehicle's maintenance record can tell you a lot about its state of repair and how reliable it is likely to be in the long run.

    Inspect the vehicle for wear and tear, damage, corrosion, and mileage. A vehicle with low mileage may be preferable because it will likely have many more years of service left.

    Consider the property's previous owners as well. It's smart to double-check the car's insurance status before buying from a private seller in Melbourne. In Australia, not having auto insurance can lead to steep fines and even the suspension of your driver's licence, so this information is crucial.

    It's a good way to make sure medical bills and car repairs are covered in case of an accident. Checking the car's insurance status could end up saving both time and money.

    abandoned burnt out car

    Content Summary

    • Buying a used car from a dealer or a private person has advantages and disadvantages.
    • Dealers relieve stress as they have experience with the process and are familiar with the documentation.
    • Dealers are required to adhere to Australian Consumer Rules and the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act's statutory warranty.
    • Dealers typically evaluate and fix any issues with used cars before selling them.
    • Dealers can assist with financing.
    • Dealerships provide a wide variety of pre-owned vehicles for comparison shopping.
    • Purchasing from a dealer means paying a higher price as they need to turn a profit.
    • Trading in a car at a dealership can get a better deal on the car you want.
    • Some salesmen can be overeager due to their reliance on sales commissions.
    • The used-car industry isn't exempt from price gouging.
    • Purchasing a brand-new car offers a tailored purchasing experience.
    • Choosing your ideal trim, colour, options, and engine is much easier when you buy brand new.
    • Modern technology in brand-new cars will save you money in the long run.
    • A manufacturer's guarantee is probably the biggest selling point of a brand-new car.
    • Depreciation is a factor to consider when buying a brand-new car.
    • Wait times for a brand-new car can be long.
    • Subaru Forester 2.5X and Volkswagen Tiguan Allspace Adventure have reduced specifications.
    • Purchasing a pre-owned car can be a better deal than purchasing a brand-new model.
    • Pre-owned cars are more affordable than brand-new cars.
    • Some pre-owned cars have been well-maintained and are still in good condition.
    • A pre-owned car's maintenance history is important to consider.
    • Pre-owned cars do not come with a manufacturer's warranty.
    • A pre-owned car's warranty can be extended.
    • You have to do more research when purchasing a pre-owned car.
    • You may have to compromise on the specific features you want when buying a pre-owned car.
    • Some sellers may not be upfront about the condition of the pre-owned car they are selling.
    • Pre-owned cars may require more maintenance and repair costs.
    • You can negotiate the price when purchasing a pre-owned car.
    • A pre-purchase inspection is recommended when purchasing a pre-owned car.
    • A pre-owned car's resale value is lower than a brand-new car.

    Frequently Asked Questions about Used Cars

    Buying a used car from a private seller can offer some benefits. Firstly, you can negotiate a lower price than you would pay at a dealership. Additionally, private sellers are typically more flexible when it comes to negotiations so that you can get a better deal overall.

    When buying a used car from a dealer, it's important to do your research beforehand. Check the car's history to ensure it hasn't been in any accidents or had major repairs. Additionally, inspect the car thoroughly to ensure it's in good condition inside and out. Finally, bring the car for a test drive to ensure that it's comfortable and everything works properly.

    It's possible to negotiate the price of a used car at a dealership, but the extent of negotiation may be limited. This is because dealerships have less flexibility when negotiating prices and may be less willing to budge on price than private sellers.

    You can often trade in your current car when buying a used car from a dealer in Melbourne. When you trade in your car, the dealer will assess its value and offer you a trade-in price that can be applied towards the purchase of your new car.

    To ensure you get the best trade-in value for your car, you can do some research ahead of time to determine its market value. For example, you can use online valuation tools to get an idea of what your car is worth based on its make, model, age, and condition. It's also a good idea to clean and tidy up your car before bringing it to the dealership.

    Remember that the trade-in value offered by the dealer may be lower than what you could get by selling your car privately. However, trading in your car can be a convenient option since you don't have to worry about advertising it, dealing with potential buyers, or negotiating the sale price.

    Research is the best way to find a reputable dealer when buying a used car. Check online reviews to see what other customers have said about the dealership. Ask for recommendations from friends and family members. Finally, research the dealership's history and reputation to ensure a good track record.

    Scroll to Top